Key takeaways
- Asphalt shingles are familiar, flexible and widely available.
- Metal roofs shed weather fast and have long lifespans.
- Installation quality matters as much as material.
- Ventilation and underlayment matter under both.
Look and style
Asphalt shingles come in many colors and textures. Metal offers clean lines in standing seam or a classic panel look, and stone-coated steel imitates shake and tile.
Look at samples against your siding and brick before choosing.
Weather performance
Both can perform well when installed correctly. Metal sheds snow and rain fast and resists fire. Impact-rated asphalt handles hail better than basic shingles.
Wind ratings depend on the product and the installation.
Noise and comfort
With solid decking and underlayment, metal is no louder in the rain than other roofs. Good attic ventilation helps both roofs stay cooler.
Insulation under the roof helps too.
Repairs and longevity
Asphalt shingles can be repaired shingle by shingle. Metal needs matching panels or trim, and repairs are less frequent.
Both last longer when kept clean and inspected.
Quick answers
Is metal roofing worth it?
Many owners choose it for longevity and appearance. We explain the tradeoffs so you can decide.
Does a metal roof make my home hotter?
Light colors reflect heat, and ventilation and underlayment matter more than the metal itself.
Can I get a metal roof over my existing shingles?
Sometimes, but a tear-off lets us inspect the deck, and we usually recommend it.




